“Mama, I’m a girl”

When I look back at my parenting life, I don’t see pivotal moments standing out as the sea change of our lives. Sure, every once in a while life changes in the blink of an eye and you don’t see it coming. But more often, for every pivotal moment we have experienced, there have been months and years of signs leading up to that moment. These signs give us clues to the road ahead so that by the time that pivotal moment comes, even though it might still be an emotional kick to the gut and we don’t feel fully prepared, we have had some guidance leading us to the right decision to make.

As a parent, I have learned to trust my instincts, because they are fueled by those clues. Those clues carry us forward to a moment that, in the end, will be but a flash of time propelling us forward to those next months and years that will inform our split-second reaction at the next pivot in our path.

One such pivotal moment came a year and a half ago. I was working in my home office, the door open so I could hear my kiddos playing in the living room. I had one ear cocked for squabbles as I tried to meet a deadline when my seven-year-old little boy crept in. He came up to me for a snuggle, then pushed away and stood in what was probably supposed to be a casual stance, except I could see the nerves behind it.

“Mama, I’m a girl.”

I won’t say that I didn’t feel my heart shatter at that moment. I wasn’t expecting those words right then, surrounded by the detritus of my working day and wishing desperately that my husband were home to face this with me. But at the same time, I wasn’t really surprised.

I was, however, deeply afraid. Terrified for my child, who had already struggled so much in the face of friends and acquaintances who didn’t understand a little boy who had a deep love for both Minecraft and sparkly pink skirts, foam swords and long hair. A little boy who wanted to get his ears pierced like his big sister and could wrestle with the best of them. So many stereotypical expectations for how girls and boys should behave slapped him in the face every day, and he had just made his life so, so much harder with those four words. I was terrified of how the world would treat him now.

That fear tempted me to brush his words off as childish fantasy, something that could be postponed and maybe forgotten.

Thank goodness for instincts. Because those instincts reminded me that this precious little boy already felt so much pain for being pressured by the world to hide his true self. And danger comes from within as well as without. You can’t hide who you are without facing serious consequences. Self-harm, suicide attempts, body dysphoria, eating disorders — these are all internal risks faced by children whose gender does not match their genitalia.

“Mama, I’m a girl.”

My heart stuttered, but my mouth worked.

“Okay.”

And I pulled her in for another hug, a big one. She left the room to go back to playing and I put my head down on my desk and cried. As our new reality sank in, though, I realized that we had been living this new reality for a long time. Since she was a toddler and went into her sister’s closet for the most fabulous dresses she could find. Since she was just starting to talk and asked when she could cut her penis off because it didn’t belong. Since she started preschool and wanted to wear pink every day. Since she started kindergarten and gained the social awareness that most boys didn’t choose “the girl snack” at school or wear girl’s clothes, so she started hiding her needed pink in socks under tall rain boots so no one would see them.

We had weathered that pivotal moment and going forward, we had a new life to live. But not really. Our words changed. “She” not “he.” “Her” not “him.” But the exact same kid. With the same heart, the same dreams, the same joyful hugs and the same hope for the future. To be happy. It’s worth overcoming my fear of the unknown to have a happy kid. No doubts there at all.

11 thoughts on ““Mama, I’m a girl”

  1. this is wonderful thank you for sharing,
    i never understood why so many people think it’s strange if a boy wears a dress or if a girl wants to rough house, one of my sons used to wear pink and dresses all the time, when he started kindergarten, he started wearing his “girl” clothes on the weekend, he also stopped wearing his pjs to school too, no one ever said he had to stop wearing those clothes, but i always wondered if he stopped due to what the the “social norm” is(although i don’t believe in the social norm)
    luckily me and my husband and our other 4 kids always let him and each other be…….well our selves!!! he’s older now and he sometimes wears pink, or dresses, he and his younger brother just got their nails painted by their older sister, my oldest son, who by society is considered a “real boy”(i hate that) loves the color purple and was glad that his school shirt, given by the school for his class was purple last year, my youngest daughter is as tough as they come who loves climbing trees, playing every sport, rides dirt bikes and plays with barbies, my oldest loves to swim and wear cut off jean shorts, play with makeup, as well as sports shorts and does not like to wear dresses, my husband grows a beard in a day, lol, then shaves his face, he’s look is ever changing, i myself, sport a buzz cut,
    we should be free to be who we want to be, our kids should be free to live happy, they should be free to dance and wear dresses, rough house and climb trees, wear pink or blue no matter what gender they are, gender does not make us who we are,—— we make us who we are!!!! every child is beautiful inside and out and every parent has the right and choice to love and stand up for the rights of our children, and guide them, and along the way maybe guide the people around us to better the world, by being open minded and think & act more like a child, with pure sweetness, realness and kindness!!
    those 3 words are so simple and yet so terrifying and at the same time beautiful, ” I’m a girl” and your girl is so lucky to have you as her mama!!!!
    thank you for posting!!!!! you are beautiful!!!! and so is your husband and your girls!!!!!
    🙂

  2. Thank you, thank you. As someone who’s partner came out to them as a transsexual woman 8 years and 2 kids into our relationship, I greatly appreciate the acceptance and love you are giving your daughter. I can only imagine how much pain and suffering my ex would have been spared had her parents accepted her as she was at the age of 7. There will still undoubtedly be pain and suffering, as society as a whole has not yet accepted LGBTQ families in their myriad of forms, but your love and support will give her the solid base she needs to be able to keep true to herself. Much love to you.

  3. I am so, so happy you are sharing this journey with us. And kudos to your entire family for living as your truest selves. It’s a brave way to live, regardless of circumstances. xo

  4. Love, love, love!! I can’t wait to hear more of your story. I have a child that flirts on that line between “tom boy” and BOY boy (s/he’s still quite young) and my response is also always, “Okay.” Because it is, and s/he will be.

  5. Thanks so much for sharing this – sounds like your daughters have a very smart, strong, and devoted mama!

  6. I really enjoyed reading this, and I’m so happy to see this perspective getting “out there” in the world!

Share Some Comment Love

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s